Showing posts with label Pandemic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pandemic. Show all posts

Sunday, February 15, 2026

Review: Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel

Station Eleven has a fun premise but a messy execution. A deadly pandemic hits Toronto and wipes out 99% of humanity. The narrative unfolds across multiple timelines in the decades before and after a fictional SARS-like virus emerges, all revolving around the lives of film star Arthur Leander and his connections. Twenty years after the pandemic, civilization has collapsed, and mankind lives on in small clusters of families scattered about the land. There is no electricity and people live by hunting in the forests and scavenging relics of the past.

The novel contrasts characters who drift through their lives with those who purposefully construct meaning. Arthur’s best friend, Clark, who had originally wished to become an actor, works as a coach for business executives. For his work, he interviews a woman about one such executive, and she gives a diagnosis of the ills of the modern era:

“[Adulthood]’s full of ghosts. … I’m talking about these people who’ve ended up in one life instead of another and they are just so disappointed. Do you know what I mean? They’ve done what’s expected of them. They want to do something different but it’s impossible now, there’s a mortgage, kids, whatever, they’re trapped. Dan’s like that. … But I don’t think he even realizes it. You probably encounter people like him all the time. High-functioning sleepwalkers, essentially.”

This quote captures the main themes explored as we get to know our broad cast of characters. Arthur is one of these “sleepwalkers”: he escapes his birthplace of the tiny island off the coast of British Columbia for the big, anonymous city of Toronto, but leaves university to become an actor. His career progresses in a blur of parties and fortune. He falls into a relationship with Miranda: she needed a refuge from her abusive relationship, he liked that she was from his place of birth and unconnected to Hollywood. He just as quickly falls into an affair with the woman who becomes his second wife, and then soon after, begins a relationship with his third wife. Other characters at varying times also avoid confronting the real world in front of them, or the unhappiness within themselves. Frank, the brother of the paparazzo who tried to save Arthur’s life, spends the first days of the pandemic writing public relations fluff for a wealthy philanthropist, allowing him to put off thinking about the world changing and what his place in it will be. 

Miranda, on the other hand, is far more conscious of her goals and decision-making. Following her divorce, she pursues a career in shipping because the office environment is a calm and serene contrast to her cramped and chaotic student apartment she had shared with her abusive boyfriend. She creates an extensive graphical sci-fi novel for nobody — or rather, for her own personal satisfaction, not money or fame. Her comics share their title with this novel, and survive long past her own death. The paparazzo, Jeevan, treats his job with mercenary-like detachment, but plans to become a paramedic: he wanted to be the type of guy people turn to in a crisis. Although his plans derail in the wake of the outbreak, he finds purpose in settling down and starting a family, and rebuilding society.

The climax fits into this theme disjointedly: twenty years post-apocalypse, a prophet has arisen and is violently bringing “salvation” to the world. Over the course of the novel, the Prophet captures and kills several characters we become familiar with, before ultimately being assassinated by a member of his own movement who we barely know. Although the Prophet is the main antagonist in the post-pandemic scenes, his character is underdeveloped. His belief that everything happens for a reason leads him to conclude that the pandemic was divine intervention. This teleological definition of purpose is different from the purposiveness explored through the other characters. Religion and radical movements are of course sources of meaning and purpose in life, but this angle was explored simplistically. I wondered if the author had plotted out one storyline, and then not course-corrected this plotline when her character exploration took her into different thematic territory. 

Indeed, I wondered why the author centered the story around a pandemic at all. The major themes were most compellingly developed in the prepandemic timelines, while the apocalypse felt like an unnecessary narrative frame. The sleepwalker theme as well as the author’s other comments about interpersonal connection (e.g., Arthur’s relationship with his friend, V—“I used her as a repository for my thoughts. I think I stopped thinking of her as a human being reading a letter”) and of being known or observed (small island life, urban anonymity, paparazzi spying) were interesting, and explored well. The post-apocalyptic world, on the other hand, is surprisingly boring. The author has clearly thought deeply about her world — there is extensive detailing of logistics — but never did I feel curious to learn more.

Perhaps it is because it is a rather sterile world. The characters necessarily focus on survival and logistics rather than lofty questions about the meaning of life. But even in stressful and existential situations, humans connect and bond with each other. This connection is mostly absent from the author’s post-pandemic plotlines. People’s emotions are instead explored through their connections with objects — old comics and magazines, items scavenged from the beforetimes, a snowglobe carried about — lending these passages a nostalgic and detached tone, and one that often shifts into a critique of consumerism.

I think the author’s underestimation of the emotional needs of humans even in desperate situations also limits her handling of the Prophet. His rise is portrayed as incomprehensible and he and his followers are one-dimensionally zealous. Naturally, writing in the early 2010s, the author would have had no knowledge of the reactionary and fascistic movements that gained steam after the 2020 pandemic outbreak. But much older works have better captured similar vitriolic and religious reactions to plagues, as well as the more positive emotional responses that arise in their wake.

The novel tells the stories of creatives: actors, writers, photographers, musicians. The last few days of civilization are told by television news and newspaper columns. There is something missing entirely: politics. No government body guides behavior or organizes responses. The characters do not remark on this absence — except for noting the failure of the national guard to save them. Nor do we see nascent political bodies form in the ashes of civilization. Excluding the authoritarian orders of the Prophet (and perhaps the Conductor’s benignly dictatorial control over the travelling orchestra), everything appears to be managed through easy, unanimous, anarchistic consensus. Perhaps the author believes that with self-actualization taking a back seat to basic survival, political disagreement vanishes. The right-wing attacks on science and the state in response to COVID stay-at-home orders shred that belief. Indeed, reading the novel with all the hindsight of the 2020s, it is surprising that the Prophet does not appear to be capitalizing off the fears and anxieties of his followers. Politics is how humans collectively determine purposeful activity (or, as it were, “sleepwalk” into climate change or through pandemics). Collective negotiation of purpose is far more challenging than individual determination of purpose, and so its absence is notable. 

The novel is now an HBO TV show. The author often composes her scenes as if they were television shots. While this style is not particularly literary, I imagine it made for a more straight-forward adaptation. The unevenness and holes in the themes that plague the novel may also translate better to a series of cohesive television episodes.

Saturday, January 24, 2026

Review: Hamnet by Maggie O'Farrell

The author is too charmed by her main character, Agnes (Anne) Hatheway. This is not uncommon in literature, but I think there are some interesting insights into how this particular version of the trope reflects our times.

This fictionalized version of William Shakespeare’s wife, Agnes, is supernaturally intuitive, able to discern a person’s thoughts just by holding their hand. She is wise in the ways of plants and flouts social norms; these traits portray her as above the crude pragmatism and small-mindedness of the rest of the villagers. She passes gracefully from manic pixie dream girl to goddess mother, birthing her first daughter in the serenity of the forest.

The author has no problem subjecting her heroine to strife. Agnes’s beloved nymph-like mother dies in childbirth early in Agnes’s childhood. Her step-mother is cruel and her in-laws treat her little better. Her youngest daughter is born sickly, and needs special care. Her son dies.

The author is, however, unable to portray a real change in Agnes. At the end of the novel, Agnes is who she is at the start and throughout each of these challenges: plant-wise, norm-flouting, guided by intuition. She has climbed out of the depths of her mourning of her son, and discovered that her husband, too, was grappling with grief; and yet she has not confronted herself, her fears, her weaknesses, and transformed, in the way we expect of a novel’s heroine. Agnes is a fantasy: an ideal of womanhood and femininity that is all intuition, emotion, and connection with nature. 

This is a seductive fantasy, and so it is not surprising the author is disinclined to confront it — a necessary critique if Agnes is to undergo a character transformation. At first blush, this fantasy appears as a challenge to patriarchy: women are granted special powers, special knowledge, that men could never have. Agnes’s nurturing care and herbs are favourably contrasted to the cool, distant, and ineffective male plague doctor, for example. But underneath, there is nothing liberatory about it. Agnes achieves material wealth through the literary successes of the husband she chose based on her magical visions. This provides her a degree of emancipation, but it is granted by a man, and denied to other women. Reverence of the magic of reproduction does not challenge a system that (often violently) controls how women reproduce.

The novel foils Agnes’s intuition against masculine rationality. The author is, of course, limited by historical fact: women were overwhelmingly denied access to literacy and education. There are examples of female characters learning their letters; Agnes’s eldest daughter learns accounting and writing and takes over the running of the household. But it is not shown as liberatory, or really even useful beyond the domestic sphere. Indeed, this example serves only to show how cycles of teenage rebellion repeat, as the daughter despairs of ever being able to escape her home, just as Agnes once did. Agnes’s intuition is ultimately as useful as anything that can be taught in books. Her plant knowledge appears similarly innate — there are allusions to mentors who taught her falconing and bee-keeping and other such skills, but they happen off-page; to struggle with systematizing knowledge, or to portray trial and failure of such witchy skills might dampen the fantasy.

We could contrast this with Virginia Woolf’s thought experiment about the importance of education and training in A Room of One’s Own. Conveniently, she picks a near-identical character: William Shakespeare’s sister. Woolf emphasizes the lack of education that makes up women’s oppression:

She had no chance of learning grammar and logic, let alone of reading Horace and Virgil. She picked up a book now and then, one of her brother's perhaps, and read a few pages. But then her parents came in and told her to mend the stockings or mind the stew and not moon about with books and papers.

Indeed in Woolf’s view, motherhood is a source of oppression, not power.

So is Hamnet rooted in the past? A pre-Woolf vision of feminine empowerment? Not at all. Indeed the book ought to be read in the context of modern debates over motherhood: natural versus medicated births, the trauma arising from one’s “birth plan” not being followed, the way caring for a special needs kid shapes your decision-making. Agnes, it goes without saying, is on the side of natural births and at-home births (or, at-forest births, as it were). She fits in with the spirituality of the “wellness industry”. 

In place of character growth, the author focuses on lushly painting intense emotions. She wields language unusually to do so; the entire novel is told in the present tense. She leans heavily on lists of three — a pattern so distracting that the reader should try her best to put it out of mind and simply allow the redundant adjectives to wash over her. Her unique style is very effective for those dreamlike moments of life, like the depths of grief, where even the smallest experiences feel sharp yet disconnected from ordinary life. It is also effective when the narrative shifts from following Agnes to following inanimate things: some of the most memorable passages trace the journey of a plague-carrying flea and a news-laden letter. Her choice of style is less effective when narrating the more routine aspects of life, like business negotiations. In these scenes, the prose heightens the importance of everything yet weighs it down in its excess of lush detail. It is sensuous prose, relishing in being and feeling.

And so we have a novel that emphasizes intuition and feeling. We have a superhuman, who inherits her elevated sensitivity from her mother, and passes it on to her children. We have a book that revels in the magic and beauty of motherhood. It is a heady combination. It is also a familiar combination. The name that we gave to that 20th century movement that celebrated irrationality over reason, Übermenschen, naturalism and a fantastical version of maternity is, of course, fascism.

Sunday, September 1, 2024

Review: The Saint of Bright Doors by Vajra Chandrasekera

This is an ambitious, vivid debut novel. The retelling of the story of Buddha’s son was clever and fresh, and meaningful even if you are not acquainted with the mythology. The prose was elegant and evocative and flowing. The world felt packed with mysteries, swirling with people and politics. The fantasy version of Sri Lanka felt so fun to explore, and the author deftly wove in the scars of colonialism, and its relationship to fascist popular uprisings and religious fundamentalism, and the way political violence is given cover by a liberal tolerance more concerned with bureaucracy and comfortable vacations in the mountains than halting pandemics and pogroms. The pandemic setting also felt eerily familiar: the narrative is very aware of who is masked, which strangers intrude within breathing distance.

But I felt like overall it came together not quite right. Some scenes had awkward transitions and some events were unclear; I had to reread a passage to confirm that a key character had actually died, and it didn’t always feel natural why a chapter started where it did. The mysteries didn’t unravel at the right rate; given the prominence of the Bright Doors, their connection to other worlds felt insufficiently dwelled upon, and was overshadowed by a somewhat out-of-nowhere appearance of a long-lost lover. I expected more coherence between the various mysteries of time shifting, doors, devils and prophecies. Perhaps their seeming disjointedness is given cohesion by familiarity with South Asian folklore. 

The ending also came a little suddenly. From the very first pages of the book, we learn Fetter’s shadow has been torn from him. At the emotional climax of the book, we suddenly learn the narrator has been Fetter’s shadow all along, and we cease seeing the world through Fetter’s eyes as the shadow sets out to complete its own goals. This reveal was well done, and I enjoyed revisiting parts of the story with this knowledge. It was also a clever way to resolve the contradiction between Fetter swearing to never kill again with the prophecy that Fetter would end his father’s life: Fetter’s shadow played the role of assassin (via an ignominious mode of death) while Fetter played the role of non-violent dissenter. Fetter is lighter than air, the shadow operates by causing pain, disgust, indigestion, shame. They form a yin/yang. 

However with this thesis/antithesis established, I felt the lack of synthesis at the end rather unfulfilling: Fetter remains blocked off from his shadow, and more distant and difficult to read than ever. Perhaps it is the author’s intent for Fetter to fully reject forever the use of violence as “the only way to change the world” — his mother’s mantra. A permanent separation of shadow and body achieves that. On the other hand, a synthesis of shadow and brightness would indicate an acceptance of both violence and non-violence. However, in the final page Fetter indicates that he has achieved nearly this latter transformation — he continues to reject violence by his hands while supporting a movement that is willing to use force when necessary to overthrow their government. So then why did his shadow leave him, separate from him?

The crux of the issue is, I think, how the author tried to approach the problem of political revolution in fiction. An author has, broadly, two choices: (1) the main character(s) can play the central role, acting as world-changing heroes (Babel), or (2) the main character can play a small role, some side battle in a bigger war (For Whom The Bell Tolls, Wheel of Time). The Saint of Bright Doors tries to have it both ways: (1) the main character is prophesied to kill his father, and (2) the main character is but a small part of a dynamic, growing movement. While the objective of (1) is completed, the day is not yet saved, and the movement built by Fetter’s friends (2) is poised to contest power. However, Fetter is strangely absent in both aspects: (1) it is his shadow that takes agency in the first arc, and (2) Fetter’s friends who take agency in the second arc. As a result, Fetter’s arc is mainly to drift through the story, and come to terms with his relationships with his parents, while others get the political work done.

Sunday, March 3, 2024

Review: Conspirituality by Julian Walker, Matthew Remski and Derek Beres

There's a banger of a long-form essay somewhere here. Unfortunately, in book form, the argument felt a bit padded.

This book examines a fascinating phenomenon that came to a head in 2020-2021 at the height of the COVID pandemic: the surprising affinity between far-right/fascist politics and the health and wellness industry. As the authors point out, this is not a novel phenomenon; the story of yoga's westernization is one of colonial anxiety about racial decline, while the history of eugenics has long married a health-conscious striving for purity with racism and reactionary politics.

So at the start of the modern yoga movement (...) we have a bizarre colonial collision. Europeans, afraid of racial decline as the borders of empire became porous through global trade and increased long-haul travel, concocted an exercise ideology to defend and restore the once-proud national body against corruption. Indian modernizers grabbed hold of this strongman aesthetic, mingled it with Scandinavian gymnastics, and then consecrated it with yoga exercises reconstructed from the medieval period. They faced east to salute the sun and sculpt a new national body, purged of foreign influences and colonial shame, a body that can carry a torch of ancient wisdom onto the modern global stage.

By 2020, the health and wellness industry had evolved into a network of small businesses, magazines, multi-level marketing corporations, and social media influencers. Facing rising rents and the cut-throat competition of capitalism, those who were able to earn a living in this sphere often found themselves needing to combine many aspects of these industries. Yoga studios discovered class fees were insufficient for making rent and so sold yoga instructor classes (a sort of MLM scheme) and essential oils (often via MLMs) and became instagram influencers. The philosophy of the wellness industry aligns perfectly with capitalism: you alone are responsible for your own health; your choices (and purchases) and hard work can lead you to success.

COVID was a perfect disaster to radicalize this group of people. On the one hand, (necessary and reasonable) restrictions against gathering in person prevented many of these businesses from operating. On the other hand, the individualistic approaches of the wellness industry were particularly ill-suited to combat health issues that required entire communities to act in unison to protect their most vulnerable. The wellness community was already primed to be skeptical of the medical community; vaccine skepticism was already high and herbal solutions and other such remedies were often preferred over clinically proved treatments. This group found a natural political ally with another group with similar distrust in collective solutions over individual rights, fury at government-mandated limits to in-person business operation, and skepticism over institutional health guidelines: the alt-right.

The authors explore how both extreme political parties and wellness industry proponents show overlap with cults. Members of these groups similarly dismiss evidence that does not fit within their worldview (using distrust of institutions, etc, to do so) and burn relationships with people that resist their beliefs. At least one of the authors was a survivor of a cult, and recognized many common patterns of the alt-right and wellness community rhetoric in their own experiences.

One of the strengths of this book was its empathy for all parties involved. The frantic communications from the government in the early days of the pandemic were confusing and contradictory, if understandable. The medical community has behaved in ways that corrode trust: events like the Tuskegee Syphilis trial are a stain upon our professsion, while at the individual level, busy doctors often dismiss patient concerns or fail to treat them like holistic human beings. Those who care for people that have become wept into proto-fascist politics have to find a line somewhere that allows them to maintain a relationship with those they love without being enablers themselves.

The authors don't quite have the answers for solving this problem, but because it is so multi-faceted it is a really hard nut to crack. Improve scientific literacy (and that includes not just pointing to peer reviewed articles as the arbiter of All Things True), integration of health within community networks in ways not mediated by money, regaining of trust between institutions and people. How do we get there in a way that doesn't further provoke the frustrations of people upset at government overreach?

Sunday, April 9, 2023

Review: The Betrothed by Alessandro Manzoni

I used to read a lot of historical fiction — the Outlander series by Diana Gabaldon, the Sharpe series by Bernard Cornwell, The Pillars of the Earth by Ken Follett, the list goes on. Historical fiction can serve to highlight the progress we’ve made — and it does sometimes: my favourite parts of Outlander involve time-travelling nurse Claire Beauchamp trying to recreate 20th century medical technology within the limits of 1740s Scotland. In practice, however, positive progress is often limited to highlighting how much more violent past societies were in their oppression of women – usually for titillation (Outlander is an example of this tendency too). Much of the historical commentary instead has a nostalgic, reactionary element to it: “we used to build gorgeous buildings”, “warfare used to be more noble”, “we were all happier when we were farmers living under the guidance of a kind Laird”, “we used to be faithful”. The choice of writing a novel set in the past implicitly makes a few political claims. This period has some particular value to understand at our current moment in time, or this period did something right (or maybe wrong?) that makes it a good setting for exploring love, loss, or some other aspect of human nature.

The Betrothed is a historical fiction novel set in the 1620s and written in the 1820s. Reading it in the 2020s makes the implicit political claims in Alessandro Manzoni’s choice of setting murkier to understand: the pressing political concerns of the mid-nineteenth century and how contemporary readers would have viewed the seventeenth century are not so front of mind. The 1820s were post-Enlightenment, post-French Revolution, with the capitalist class encroaching upon the power of the aristocratic class. The 1620s were feudal, dominated by power struggles between a powerful church and the aristocratic class and their thuggish bravi. Italian territories of the 1820s were governed by the Hapsburg empire, while Italian territories of the 1620s were governed by the Spaniards.

Manzoni, an aristocrat, grapples with the concepts of power and laws, the role of the (aristocratic) individual versus the State in charity, and the decline of Catholic morals, and the 1620s backdrop helps him explore how these facets of society had changed over time.

Our opening scene features village priest Don Abbondio accosted by the local baron Don Rodrigo’s hired hit men, who threaten him into not marrying the betrothed lovers Lucia and Renzo. By the law of the land, it was of course illegal to coerce people into performing or not performing marriages. Renzo is informed so by a barrister (Chapter 3), but when the barrister realizes his client would be facing the militarily mighty Don Rodrigo in court, he cowers in fear and joins the side of the law-flouting Don Rodrigo instead. Given the weakness of the law to the power of violence wielded by the nobility, how should Don Abbondio have reacted? The answer is the church: the novel devotes some fifteen pages (Chapter 25-26) to the chastisement of Don Abbondio by saintly Cardinal Federico Borromeo, who explains that Don Abbondio should have escalated the matter to the church, and watched out for his flock of parishioners rather than for his own skin.

A fourth faction complicating the Law/Nobility/Church power struggle is that of the masses, and we see their potential for power in the bread riots of Chapters 12-13. After two years of famine, aristocratic politician Grand Chancellor Antonio Ferrer attempts to soothe the masses who are furious at the rising bread prices by setting a price cap on bread, like “an aging woman who thinks she can be young again simply by altering her birth certificate.” While “orders less inane and unfair had [previously] not been executed (...) since they were so unrealistic”, the masses, in their dumb hunger for bread, ensured that this particular rule was enforced, attributing the lack of bread not to the famine but to the tyranny of the landowners, the bourgeois, and “anyone, in short, who had either a little or a lot or was reputed to have some”. The narrative is very sympathetic to the plight of the bakers, who must sell bread as if it's priced at 33 liras a bushel while the going rate is 80 liras a bushel, and face penalties for not selling their wares. While we do not see any starving peasants, we are shown several scenes of violent looters, participants running from the riots carelessly letting bread rolls fall from their overflowing baskets and arms. I took this chapter to be in part a reaction to the French Revolution of 1789, one that is suddenly aware of the power of crowds (“All that was missing was an occasion, a spark, an instigation of some sort to transform words into action”) but also one firmly believing that mob rule will lead to a degenerate state.

We see these same forces at work as the plague breaks out in Chapters 31-33: those in charge of writing laws and their learnèd consultants are stupid, ineffectual, corrupt, and break apart the ties of community, while the masses continue to fixate on conspiratorial explanations for their misery (a clandestine organization of noxious unguent spreaders) rather than material evidence (an airborne disease).

Amidst the senseless frenzy of the masses and the shortsighted overstepping of liberty of the legal system, there are nonetheless several examples given of good being done in the world. However, these are united by one principle: they are examples of highborn people following the ways of God and helping the less fortunate through charity. The turning point of the novel is the “miraculous” conversion of the Nameless One, from his days of marauding debauchery to becoming a model aristocrat. Upon his conversion, he uses his resources to rescue Lucia from the clutches of Don Rodrigo, and gives ample charitable gifts to her family to restore the balance upset by Don Rodrigo’s threats at the start of the novel. Contrasted with the bread riots, Cardinal Frederico, who “could be living in the lap of luxury”, is praised for feeding the hungry for bread from his own plate. These charitable gestures inspire a tailor to give food to a poor widow—this, presumably, is seen as a more just solution to a famine. The virtuous Fra Cristoforo, wealthy by birth and proud by nature who similarly miraculously converts to the ways of the Lord, helps the sufferers of the plague through self-sacrificing devotion in contrast to the heartless, cruel public health measures implemented by the Tribunal of Health. This emphasis on individual actions runs throughout the novel. “Do good to as many people as you can (...) and you will be rewarded many times over with faces that lift your spirits.”

In the 19th century, moral obligation had given way to legal formality. Where once one’s word of honour would suffice, now legal contracts were required. Where once noblesse oblige and the charity and protection of the church ensured the welfare of the commoners, now state intervention into the price of bread or into disease management prevailed. Manzoni appears to be commenting that, sure, the olden times had their issues with individuals (and their bravi) acting badly, but the Church and the charity of the good were there to counteract them. Now, we have just the State and the masses, and look how senseless that can be. Is there still a role remaining for the pious aristocrat?

Poor politics aside, I want to highlight two stand-out parts of the novel. The first is the portrait of Gertrude (Chapters 9-10). Her aristocratic father wishes to not divide his estate amongst his children, and so grooms Gertrude from an early age to become a nun. Despite these social pressures, Gertrude discovers the joy of love, which would be denied her were she to become a nun. However, the path to becoming a nun has been carved out for her, and to deviate from it requires upsetting every social and familial relationship she has. While Gertrude ultimately lacks the courage to leave the life others have created for her, her inner monologue is written with such empathy and compassion that it still feels like a very fresh investigation into social conditioning and the meaning of enthusiastic consent versus coercion. I think this same empathy allows Manzoni to portray plague survivors in a way that likely strikes readers of the 2020s as more accurate and true than it would have to readers of the 2010s even. There is a scene in which the star-crossed fiancé unites with a friend after the plague, and both feel out of practice socially but hunger for community and recount the trauma of the pandemic and how they’ve survived it. I, at least, have had a few of those conversations.

Finally, the translation by Michael Moore is vivid and lyrical.

And one last note: I had originally thought to write on the role of providence in the novel, however I really enjoyed Robert S. Dombrosk's treatment of the subject and direct the reader there instead.

Saturday, June 5, 2021

Review: The White Castle by Orhan Pamuk

I picked up this book because I thought it would be interesting to read some literature from a non-Anglo/Northern European author, and because the audiobook was available from my library. I was caught quite by surprise by the role the plague played in this book - what timing to read it during the coronavirus pandemic. It was a little uncanny to see concerns of social distancing/contagious disease play out, written from the 1980s and set in the 1600s yet read in 2020: people anxiously following social distancing norms, other people decrying the whole thing as a hoax, others frantically trying to trace down all data they could in hopes of understanding the disease, the strange love and resentment that builds from being cooped up so closely with another person, the fear of a second wave, the concerns about economic collapse if the markets are not re-opened...

The White Castle reminded me of Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell in that it was chiefly about a relationship between two men, that ranges from a hierarchical relationship, to one of collaboration and productive research, to an antagonistic relationship. Jonathan Strange does go through his "candles in heads" phase of madness and The White Castle's Hoja goes through a similar "why am I who I am" search. However what I love so much about Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell is the dry sense of humor, the strange fantasy world, and the absurdity of some parts. The White Castle lacked these elements. Further, there are ways I worry I am like Mr Norrell, ways I wish I was more like Jonathan Strange, and parts of Jonathan Strange I see in myself. Except for a drive to understand myself, and an appreciation for science, I didn't really identify with the narrator nor with Hoja. Because the story was so driven by character arcs and so little by plot, I think this diminished my enjoyment of the book.

The question of identity at the end of the book was interesting. I think I like the interpretation better that it was the Italian man that returned to Italy. The actions of the "narrator" work better if carried out by Hoja (and indeed also the actions of the sovereign, who seemed to take great joy in understanding two men as independent and very different people, also suggest as much). It doesn't make sense to me that the Italian man would seek company in a slave.

The pace was meditative, but not tediously slow. It was a relaxing read, if not gripping.